All Mine To Give (1957) Stealing Orphans All Mine to Give (British title: The Day They Gave Babies Away) is a 1957 Technicolor melodrama film directed by Allen Reisner and starring Glynis Johns, Cameron Mitchell, and Rex Thompson. When first one parent, then the other dies, six children have to look after themselves in the American west of the mid-19th century. This story is based on a true-life story set in Wisconsin, based on an article The Day They Gave Babies Away by Dale Eunson and his wife